Many a times my clients who are in the process of launching a Newspaper, ask me
which Page Layout software to install. I have always advised them to see it from
an operators' point of view. For users migrating from older applications like Adobe
PageMaker, Indesign would be an ideal choice. Also Indesign allows better
integration with other Adobe Applications like, Photoshop, Illustrator & Acrobat,
e.g. making PDF files becomes easier. However, QuarkXPress has reigned supreme
in this application area for long & so has its own strengths too.
Please find below a broad Comparison between the
two Competitors, based on available information:
Comparison Table
The Basic comparison |
QuarkXPress |
InDesign |
Operating system |
Classic Mac OS, Mac OS, Microsoft Windows |
Windows and Mac OS |
Language |
Multilingual |
24 Language |
Quality vs Quantity |
Feature-rich software |
Quality rich software |
License |
Lifetime license |
Subscription base License |
Colors |
Its support hex chrome color |
It doesn’t |
Page Size |
48 Inch Square (QX 6.0) |
216 Inch Square |
Installation |
Concurrent installation is prohibited |
Concurrent installation permitted |
Export JDF files |
Yes |
No |
Convert print to HTML for use in Dreamweaver |
Yes |
No |
Design web page compatible with Dreamweaver |
Yes |
No |
Import flash swf files for pdf |
No |
Yes |
Support for illustrator layers |
No |
Yes |
Drag and Drop from illustrator |
No |
Yes |
Photoshop transparency control |
Yes |
No |
Photoshop-like palette controls |
Yes |
No |
Control Photoshop spot colors |
Yes |
No |
Conclusion
QuarkXPress focused on adding to more new features
rather than improving previous tools and features. On one side, Quark focuses
on improving various types of HTML tools so that you can create multiple
layouts in a single document, but another side their typographic and layout
feature is not updated. So why we called QuarkXPress is feature-rich software.
Adobe InDesign does not focus on only adding a
feature; they try to improve the previous feature as well. For, i.e. Adobe
InDesign has a Typographic feature more powerful than QuarkXPress, but what
Adobe did, they improve in the newer version of InDesign 2.0 as well. Adobe
InDesign focuses on improving performance and speed, so that’s why Adobe
InDesign gives better performance than any other competitive software.
Compiled by:
Chandan
Datta, Compu Care Infotech
Address:
B'C'#3, Block-II, 2nd Floor, 'Calcutta Greens Commercial Complex', 1050/2,
Survey Park, Kolkata-700 075 (Mob.:+9198300 40811; E-Mail:dattachandan1960@gmail.com;
Website: http:\\compucare4u.business.site)
Comments
Post a Comment